What is the AGPL License?

Understanding the AGPL License

The GNU Affero General Public License (AGPL) is a free software license designed to ensure users have the freedom to use, modify, and distribute software. It builds upon the standard GPL by addressing software use over a network, making it particularly relevant for web applications and Software as a Service (SaaS).

Key Features

• Network Interaction Clause: The AGPL includes a provision that requires any modified version of the software that is accessed over a network to be made available to users under the same license. This ensures that all users, even those interacting with the software remotely, benefit from the same freedoms as users running the software locally.
• SaaS Loophole Closure: One of the primary motivations for the AGPL was to close the loophole that allowed companies to offer software as a service without sharing the source code of their modifications. The AGPL ensures that any enhancements or changes made to the software must be shared with the community, maintaining the spirit of open source collaboration.

Differences Between AGPL and GPL

The AGPL and GPL share many similarities in promoting software freedom, but the AGPL includes specific provisions for software accessed over a network. While the GPL allows software to be used without sharing modifications if it's not distributed, the AGPL mandates that network-based interactions also require sharing modifications, effectively extending the copyleft requirement to SaaS environments. For more on GPL linking exceptions, read here. 

Compliance Challenges

• Corporate Restrictions: Many companies find the AGPL's requirements restrictive, especially for proprietary business models. The obligation to share modifications can deter companies from using AGPL-licensed software, as it can conflict with their desire to keep proprietary innovations confidential.
• Legal Ambiguities: The AGPL's network interaction clause can be complex to interpret, leading to uncertainties in compliance. Companies must carefully navigate the legal landscape to ensure they meet the license's requirements without inadvertently exposing proprietary code.

Explore our open source license compliance solutions for effective management. 

Adoption and Industry Impact

• Corporate Resistance: Due to its stringent requirements, the AGPL is less popular among businesses compared to other open source licenses. The need to disclose modifications made to software used over a network can be seen as a significant deterrent.
• Popularity Among Application Software: Despite corporate resistance, the AGPL remains popular for certain types of open source projects, particularly those involving web applications and SaaS. Its provisions ensure that these applications remain open and collaborative.

Dual Licensing Strategy

To balance open source collaboration with commercial interests, some projects adopt a dual licensing strategy. This involves offering the software under the AGPL for open source use and providing a different license for commercial use. This approach allows companies to benefit from the software without being bound by the AGPL's strict sharing requirements, while still contributing to the open source community.

Learn about sudden license changes in open source. 

Pros and Cons

• Enhanced Freedom: Ensures that all users, including those accessing the software over a network, have access to the source code and any modifications.
• Encourages Collaboration: By requiring modifications to be shared, the AGPL fosters a collaborative environment where developers can build upon each other's work.
• Prevents Proprietary Exploitation: The AGPL closes loopholes that allow companies to benefit from open-source software without contributing back, ensuring a fairer ecosystem.

• Corporate Reluctance: Many businesses avoid AGPL-licensed software due to the requirement to disclose modifications, which can conflict with proprietary business models.
• Compliance Complexity: Understanding and adhering to the AGPL's provisions can be challenging, especially for companies unfamiliar with open source licensing.
• Limited Commercial Use: The restrictive nature of the AGPL can hinder commercial adoption and innovation, as companies may be unwilling to share their modifications.

Risks and Opportunities

• Potential Risks for Companies: The AGPL's stringent requirements can pose legal risks and compliance burdens for companies, potentially leading to inadvertent exposure of proprietary code.
• Benefits for Open Source Community: Despite the challenges, the AGPL provides significant benefits for the open source community by ensuring ongoing access to software modifications and fostering a collaborative development environment.

SaaS Loophole and the AGPL

The SaaS loophole in the GPL allows companies to provide software as a service without distributing the source code of modifications. This loophole means that GPL-licensed software used in SaaS applications does not trigger the requirement to share source code unless it is distributed. The AGPL addresses this loophole by extending the requirement to share modifications to include network interactions, ensuring that even software used over a network must remain open source.

Conclusion

The AGPL plays a crucial role in the open source ecosystem by ensuring software freedom, particularly for network-based applications. However, its stringent requirements pose challenges for corporate adoption, making it a double-edged sword in the software licensing landscape. While it promotes openness and collaboration, it also imposes significant compliance burdens that can deter commercial use.

Revenera's end-to-end solution delivers a complete, accurate SBOM while managing license compliance and security.